Disadvantages
for users of large print
-
Enlarging can emphasise the imperfections in print
-
Pictures are in black & white (and shades of grey)
-
Labels on graphics or maths symbols may need further
enlargement
-
The total head-sweep needed to read large print can be
time-consuming and tiring
-
Because of their size, large print books often do not
fit into school desks or locker
-
Their size and weight make large print books difficult
to carry
-
There are comparatively few commercially available large
print books in publication
-
The format of black and grey on white eliminates all
the colour that is available in regular books
-
Production in large print is labour intensive and expensive
-
Photocopy enlarging emphasises imperfections in letters
and pictures
-
Fractions, labels on diagrams, etc may not be enlarged
to large print size
-
The student may not be able to independently access regular
print materials resulting in functional illiteracy
-
Limited choices are available in large print for leisure
reading
-
Provision of large print may be based on other people’s
need to help rather than the student’s required print size. Perhaps
there is a history of large print usage. Perhaps there is a positive perception
by adults of the value of large print (“my grandmother uses large
print”). Perhaps eye specialists recommend it without measuring
the student’s near acuity.
Advantages
for users of large print
-
Facilitates the student’s ability to read exponents
and other small number notations in maths books
-
Useful as a transitional tool for students whose primary
literacy medium is switching from print to braille
-
Little or no instruction is needed to use large print
-
A Low Vision Clinic evaluation is not required for large
print
-
Student may be less self-conscious when reading large
print (doesnt need to use any special aids)
-
LP books are funded by the production agency, whereas
parental or other funding is required for magnifiers
Disadvantages
for users of magnifiers
Advantages
of magnifiers
-
Magnifiers allow immediate access to print anywhere
-
Maps and graphics can be viewed in true colours
-
Lower overall cost per child than large print
-
Lighter and more portable than large print
-
No ordering and waiting time for materials
-
May be more cosmetically desirable than using huge books
-
Allow greater independence (and choice in reading materials!)
-
Can be used post school
The decision to provide large print to a student should be made by the child's
educational team, following an appropriate learning media assessment.
See also Teaching the Use of Magnifiers
for Reading , Reading Exercise Chart -
three examples and Ideas for Encouraging
the use of Magnifiers.